
It is your author’s opinion (and we shall return to this theory as we continue to examine the later Canon, for it becomes quite apparent) that Watson is, in fact, lying. This story was first published in 1910, some seven years into Holmes’ retirement, and Watson would have us believe that Holmes was living a peaceful, if isolated, existence in Sussex, while Watson remained apart, in London.

It was, then, with considerable surprise that I received a telegram from Homes last Tuesday –he has never been known to write where a telegram would serve… We will return to this in a moment (and indeed, throughout the story) but first we must examine a very interesting statement. The story, therefore, is quite pivotal in terms of their relationship, for, while still guarded, Holmes is no longer able to hide the true depth of his feelings for Watson. Indeed, as the story progresses, Holmes and Watson’s bond will continue to strengthen until at long last they are finally set upon the path which will lead them to open declarations of love and affection.


Watson’s introduction to The Adventure of the Devil’s Foot is quite apropos, for this story marks a shift in Watson’s long and intimate relationship with Sherlock Holmes. In recording from time to time some of the curious experiences and interesting recollections which I associate with my long and intimate friendship with Mr. Proving his findings, however, is another matter all together, and Holmes’ experiment, with what is later revealed to be a substance called Devil’s Foot, comes dangerously close to costing both him and Watson their lives. Mortimer Tregennis himself) before Holmes has enough evidence to piece together the final solution. It’ll take a second murder (this time Mr. Despite Watson’s objections, Holmes takes up the case, and soon discovers that what should be elementary is actually quite complex. Mortimer Tregennis, then seeks Holmes’ aid in uncovering what devilry has claimed the life of his sister, and the sanity of his two brothers. Holmes goes only reluctantly, but his spirits are soon lifted, for shortly into their visit to Cornwall a sinister murder is committed. When Sherlock Holmes’ constitution takes a turn for the worse, Watson forces him to take an extended vacation in the country.

The story was first published in December of 1910. Watson collaborates this date, telling us that the story took place in the spring of 1897, and then thrice mentioning the month of March. Baring-Gould dates The Adventure of the Devil’s Foot in March of 1897.
